An auditor is liable to pay damages for loss to his client in the event of non-fulfillment of the contract. He has to examine facts and see that the members have his opinion as to the balance sheet showing the state of affairs of the company. Unless he does this, his duty will be worse than a farce. are examples to optional audits. In France the auditor's liability cannot be limited by contract or otherwise. Contractual Liability: In case of optional audits rights, duties, liabilities etc of auditor will be of contractual nature. 17(2).) Statutory auditors have joint and several liability with a company’s directors for damages arising from non-compliance with their duties. (ii) One of the Company directors did not account for the balance that he received from one of the Company’s suppliers. It is not his duty to consider what is good or what is bad policy. ), and so it appears that the auditor may be held liable to all parties in general who are interested in the affairs of the business. states that whosoever issues or signs any certificate required by law to be given or signed or relating to any fact which such certificate is by law admissible in evidence, knowing or believing that such certificate is false in any material point, shall be punishable in the same manner as if he gives a false evidence’. (1) An auditor is guilty of misfeasance if he fails to detect the omission of liabilities from the balance sheet even when such omission is apparent. are examples to optional audits. The accountant, under the Hedly Byrne Doctrine, may incur liability in the following occasions: (a) Preparing financial statements or reports for a client when it is known or expected that they are intended to be shown to and relied upon by a third party, even if the identity of the third party is not disclosed ; (b) Giving reference regarding a client’s credit­worthiness; (c) Allowing the use of the auditor’s name indiscriminately; (d) Accepting the work which is beyond the professional competence, or not obtaining the specialist advice where the report may have to include opinions of a nature outside the field of the auditor’s professional work. Candler Vs. Crane, Christmas & CO. (1951): In this case Mr. Candler, the plaintiff, claimed that he suffered a loss of investment in shares of the company as he relied on the ‘draft accounts’ which, without any change, was certified by the auditors. As in case of optional audits company auditor is liable for his negligence. (2) Statement no. (iii) The auditors on this ground are guilty of negligence. Leeds Estate Building and Investment Co. Ltd. As regards the third charge, the court held that: (i) The auditors should have asked for the Securities instead of accepting the certificate of the Company’s stockbrokers; (ii) The fraud must have been detected had the auditors asked for the securities – which could not have been produced by Ellis & Co.- as the same were charged to brokers against the loan by them to Ellis & Co. ; and. It was no excuse that the auditor had not seen the Articles when he knew of their existence. Loans at call or short notice, and the part of Ellis & Co.’s debt was wrongly included under ‘Cash at Bank and in hand, and the auditor did not disclose these debts to the shareholders. A person whose duty is to convey information to others does not discharge that duty by simply giving them so much information as is calculated to induce them, or some of them, to ask for more. 40 Lakhs annually or has capital contribution more than 25 Lakhs. Liability under Optional Audits. a) Right of access to the books of account b) Right to obtain information and explanation from officers c) Right to attend general meeting d) All of the above 135. (ii) The person, not parties to the original contract, cannot ordinarily recover damages in respect of an auditor’s negligence. Armitage Vs. 3. This loan was never separately shown in the balance sheet. Summary: An auditor was guilty of misfeasance as he gave only the ‘means of information’ and not the ‘information’ to the shareholders in respect of the untrue and incorrect state of affairs of the company. In reality, the company net worth was ‘Nil’ and most of the overstatement was due to a large block of fictitious accounts receivable. Even if he does not issue an audit certificate, it does not relieve him from incurring liability. The opinions expressed or the advice given by an auditor will not be liable to action for negligence merely because, in the light of later events, they prove to have been mistaken. Further, the auditors failed to highlight that some of the debts were time-barred. Uploader Agreement, Read Accounting Notes, Procedures, Problems and Solutions, Learn Accounting: Notes, Procedures, Problems and Solutions, Difference between Internal Auditor and Cost Auditor, Valuation of Assets and Liabilities of a Company | Auditing, Verification of Assets and Liabilities of a Company | Auditing, Verification of Assets and Liabilities | Company | Auditing. 8. Section 62 and 63 of Companies Act, 1956: If company auditor certifies fraudulent prospectus knowingly he will be charged with imprisonment up to two years with or without fine. The former occur when individuals or organisations breach a government imposed law; in other words criminal law governs relationships between entities and the state. The bankers furnished the information without assuming any responsibility. (ii) The fraud must have been detected by a thorough examination of the wages sheets by the auditors. The punishment under this act is same as for the giving or fabricating false evidence. 2. (a) The debts due to the company, from Ellis and Co. (the stockbrokers of the company) and its General Manager were mis-described and shown under wrong account head, viz. 18. (5) the Official liquidator brought on action against the directors and auditors of the Company alleging that they have failed to perform their duties and were, therefore, guilty of misfeasance. Irish Woolen Co. (2) An auditor is guilty of negligence if he fails to detect the over-valuation of work-in- progress when ample materials as evidence are available for testing the accuracy of the figures given to him. The plaintiffs suffered a loss due to inaccurate and misleading information furnished by the bankers, and so, filed a damage suit for negligence in the Court. Civil law, in contrast, deals with disputes between individuals and/or organisations. ii) Right to receive information and explanations. Proprietorships and Partnership Firms shall undergo for tax audit if crosses the certain threshold of sales. The Court held that the auditors were not guilty of negligence for not inspecting the securities as such fraud might not have been detected in view of their actual knowledge of the state of affairs at the time of each audit. Liabilities of a Company Auditor A Company Auditor is appointed under the Companies Act. (iii) The auditors argued that “in a money lending business it did not matter how old the debts were, because in the long run people would come back and pay in order to be able to obtain further advances.” The Judge decided that the auditors were guilty of negligence in their duties for: (a) Not reporting the insufficiency of the provision for bad and doubtful debts to the shareholders; and. As a result, the accounts had shown unrealized profits. Statutory law liability is the obligation that comes from a certain statute or a law which is applied to society. (d) The plaintiff suffered damages by relying on the auditor’s statement. Le Lievere and Dennes Vs. Gould (1893): The decision was – “The question of liability for negligence cannot arise at all until it is established that the man who has been negligent owed some duty to the person who seeks to make him liable for his negligence. The auditor is guilty of negligence of his duty if he fails to perform statutory duties in communicating the true position of accounts to the shareholders although such communication is made to the directors. 11. The auditor, in his report to the shareholders, merely stated that the value of the assets as shown by the balance sheet was dependent upon realisation without any comment as to the insufficiency of security. Statutory liability provides cover for defense costs, fines and penalties charged against the firm. Power and Duties of an Auditor Every auditor has a right of access to the books of account and vouchers of the company at all times, whether they are at the registered office of the company or at any other place. 628 of Companies Act): If in any return, report, certificate or other document, he makes a statement: (1) Which is false in any material fact knowing it to be a material and. He has nothing to do with the prudence or imprudence of making loans with or without security. An auditor who adopts such a course does so at his peril, and runs a very serious risk of being held judicially to have failed to discharge his duty. (Id. (ii) The defendant contended that the auditors did not report about the insufficient provision for bad and doubtful debts which resulted in inflated profits and more commission paid to the manager. Civil Liability of an Auditor for Misfeasance Means of Misfeasance Breach ((break) of trust or duty imposed by law for negligence in the performance of duties, which results in some loss or damage to the company. Statutory Auditor. It is his/her duty to report any fraud. The Central Advance and Discount Corporation Ltd. (1920). An auditor is liable to be guilty of misfeasance for signing the balance sheet blindly and has to suffer the consequences if such balance sheet is found subsequently to be incorrect. This Appeal was dismissed by the Court with cost. Article 31 of the 17 May 2006 Statutory Audit Directive requires that the European Commission studies ‘the impact of current national liability rules of the carrying out of statutory audits on European capital markets and on the insurance conditions for statutory auditors and audit firms, including an objective analysis of the limitations of financial liability. Image Guidelines 4. (2) Makes or is privy to the making of any false or fraudulent entry in any register, books of account or document belonging to the company. (3) The company brought an action against the auditors for damages on the ground that the fraud could have been detected by the auditors had they verified the petty cash in hand. Section 628 of Companies Act, 1956: If company auditor certifies any false statement knowing that it is false. Liability of auditor for branch audit is followings: v Responsibility: Even though the statutory auditor is not responsible for the work performed by the branch auditor, it is suggested that there should be sufficient liaison between the two auditors to ensure that the work is performed expeditiously. (8) The Court, in its judgment upheld the Magistrate’s order and held that the directors and the auditors were guilty of criminal liability. Vs. Heller & Partners Ltd. 6. The auditor argued that the preparation of the profit and loss account and the balance sheet was the Contract and not anything else. The company also alleged that the auditor entrusted the major work to his assistant who did not exercise reasonable skill and care to the audit. (a) The extent to which an auditor accepts responsibility should be made clear beyond the scope of misunderstanding; (b) Where an auditor specifically restricts the scope of his report or expresses appropriate reservations in a note attached to and referred to in the financial statements he has prepared or the report which he has made thereon, this can constitute a disclaimer which will be effective against any action for negligence brought against him by third parties; (c) Where an individual shareholder uses the audited annual accounts for investment decisions no action would lie against the auditor as the accounts are not normally prepared for this purpose; (d) Where the audited accounts would be used for tax assessment purposes by the Revenue Department, no action would lie in case of reliance upon accounts negligently prepared since in fact the failure to recover tax is attributable to the death or insolvency or decamping of the taxpayer, not to the negligence of the auditor; (e) The third parties entitled to recover damages will be limited to those who by reason of accountants’ negligence in preparing reports, accounts, or financial statements on which the third parties place reliance suffer financial loss in circumstances where the accountants knew or ought to have known that the reports, accounts, and the financial statements in question were being prepared for the purpose specifically or transaction which gave rise to the loss and that they would be shown to and relied on by third parties in that particular connection. “Thus, it appears that the auditor, in the absence of fraud,-does not incur liability to third parties who suffered damages for the former’s negligence. (1) The profit of the Company was inflated by (a) understating the company’s liabilities by suppression of purchase invoices and (b) overstating the value of work-in- progress; (2) The dividend was paid out of such inflated profit which resulted in payment of dividend out of capital; (3) The auditors also acted as accountants to the company; (4) The company went into liquidation; and. (iii) The directors trusted the dishonest manager for years and also the auditor’s report and declared dividends. The auditors confined their scrutiny to the evidence created and/ or held by the client, such as sales invoices and did not ask for direct confirmation of accounts balance from the customers. Mr. Justice Denning gave a verdict that the auditors were not liable to the third parties in absence of any contractual relationship between them. Authentication of Assets and Liabilities: Verification of assets and liabilities for checking their existence, valuation, completeness and disclosure in financial statements. V.18. The NCLT either suo motu or on an application made to it by the Central Government or by any person concerned, if it is satisfied that the auditor of a company has, whether directly or indirectly, acted in a fraudulent manner or abetted or colluded in any fraud by, or in relation to, the company or its directors or officers, it may, by order, direct the company to change its auditors. This report will basically discuss on the trend of auditor liability to third parties in United Kingdom (UK) and United States (US) as the liability pressure in these two countries is predominantly intense. The Statutory Auditor is liable for nonfulfillment of the terms and conditions of an agreement between him and the company who appoints him. He may conduct partial audit at his own risk. (3) “If the auditor found that a company in the course of its business was incurring liabilities of a particular kind, and that the creditors sent in their invoices after an interval, and that the liabilities of the kind in question must have been incurred during the accountancy period under audit, and that when he was making his audit a sufficient time had not elapsed for the invoices relating to such liabilities to have been received and recorded in the Company’s books, it became his duty to make specific inquiries as to the existence of such liabilities and so, before he signed a certificate as to the accuracy of the balance sheet, to go through the invoice files of the company in order to see that no invoices relating to liabilities had not been omitted.”, (4) “With regard to the Over-Valuation of Work- in-progress, it was the duty of the auditor to check the figures at which work-in-progress was brought into the balance sheet. He may be held responsible under the Contract Act ‘in failing to perform the duties’ as laid down in agreement. Terms of Service 7. The judge, in the original trial, disallowed the charge of negligence as there was a lack of contractual relationship between the auditor and the third party creditor. V.8. Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) shall get its account audited if it crosses the limit of turnover Rs. Section 539 of Companies Act, 1956: If company auditor destructs records of the company at the time of liquidation, he will be charged with imprisonment up to seven years with or without fine. He is responsible on account of negligence in performance of his duties. made an appeal in the court against the District Judge’s Order. He must not certify what he does not believe to be true. Audit of sole trading concerns, audit of partnership firms, etc. Such liability is signified where no direct contractual liability exists. (c) The existence of a large number of the company’s securities, which were in Ellis & Co’s custody and had been pledged by that firm to its customers (i.e. (5) One of the shareholders brought a criminal suit against the managing directors under Section 282 of the Companies Act 1913 (now Section 628 of Companies Act 1956 which states – Any person who makes a false statement in any returns, balance sheet, etc. He may be held responsible under the Contract Act ‘in failing to perform the duties’ as laid down in agreement. art. Consequently, dividends were paid out of capital (not out of realised profits) in pursuance of a resolution of the shareholders based upon the directors’ recommendation and upon balance sheet certified by the auditor. investors, creditors, bankers, tax departments, etc.). He had also to satisfy himself that all liabilities incurred by the Company in connection with the work so valued had been brought into account.”. Case law: Official liquidators of Karachi Bank Ltd. vs Directors and Auditors of Karachi Bank Ltd. (ii) The auditor confessed that – he would have discovered the criticality of the affairs of the bank and fraud connected with the depositors and creditors, had he examined the books and asked for an explanation. Section 197 of Indian Penal Code deals with Issuing or signing false certificate. Section 62 and 63 of Companies Act, 1956: If Company auditor unknowingly certifies false prospectus, civil liability arises. The brief outline of the case was that the bank advanced considerable amounts to its customers on loan and current accounts although the securities held were insufficient. Section 240 of Companies Act, 1956: If company auditor does not co-operate with government inspectors, he will be charged with imprisonment up to six months with or without fine. (2) An auditor is liable if he does not inspect the securities which are in the hands of third party in whose custody such assets are not ordinarily kept. Key Words: Auditor, power, duties, liabilities Introduction: An auditor, to perform his duties must have certain powers, without which it may not be possible for him to perform his duties honestly and thereby, he might be held liable for any loss which the company might suffer. Hedly Byrne & Co. Ltd. City Equitable Fire Insurance Co. Ltd. (1924): This is a case in which the directors and auditors of the company were sued by the Official Receiver (as liquidator) for damages arising out of negligence and breach of duty. Under statutory law, an auditor can be held civilly or criminally liable. : Accountants Liability to Third parties – The Hedly Byrne Decision. is liable to be imprisoned upto two years and fined.) In the case of the auditor of a sole proprietorship business or a partnership firm, the power and duties In India, the term "statutory auditor" refers to an external auditor whose appointment is mandated by law. The audits which are not legally required are called optional audits. 2. The plaintiffs brought action against the auditor for breach of duty and negligence and also claimed damages. Indian Penal Code imposes a criminal liability on the auditor. 13. This is because the auditor’s liability to clients occurs only when there is breach of contract, i.e. The audits which are legally required are called statutory audits. He remains liable for damages if he omits to verify the existence of assets. Who are eligible to appoint as statutory Auditor? The auditor who intentionally gives false evidence: (1) Upon any examination, upon oath or solemn affirmation; or. Companies Act 2016 Duties, functions, liabilities and responsibilities of auditors are further defined by MIA Statutory Requirement for Appointment of Auditors Every company must appoint an auditor at its AGM, to hold office from the conclusion of that meeting until the conclusion of the next AGM. Under the Companies Act, the liabilities of a company auditor can be grouped under two heads. Superintendent and Remembrance of Legal Affairs, Bengal Vs. Akhil Bandhu Guha and Others (1936): (1) The managing directors of Dhakeswari Cotton Mills Ltd. were also the managing directors of a newly formed company named East Bengal Jute and Cotton Mills Ltd. (2) The amount against the item ‘Deposit by others’ shown in the balance sheet of the first Company was actually arrived at by deducting the loan amount advanced to the other new company. (2) “His duty with regard to the ascertainment of unrecorded liabilities must be determined by the nature of the business carried on. LIABILITIES OF AN AUDITOR:- Following are the liabilities of an auditor:-If an auditor is guilty of negligence in the execution of his duty, he may be held liable to make good any damage resulting from that negligence. (iii) The bankers should, therefore, be exonerated from their liability for damages arising out of negligence. before the Magistrate. Copyright 9. Vs. Seear, Hasluck and Co. (1904): (1) The clerk of the audit firm compared the petty cash book with the accounts and did not verify the balance of actual cash in hand; (2) The petty-cashier misappropriated the differential amount between the actual cash that should have been and the physical cash balance in hand; and. Statutory liability: CPAs have statutory liability under both federal and state securities laws. In case where company wants to proceed legally against its auditor on the ground of negligence, the following conditions are to be fulfilled; Company must be capable of proving that auditor is negligent. Where there is nothing to excite suspicion, very little inquiry will be reasonable and sufficient. As a result, the frauds of the aforesaid nature could not be detected during audit. The auditor may be held liable for breach of trust or responsibility and for wilful misconduct and default, depending on the circumstances of each case. The Judge held that the auditor was guilty of negligence for not performing his duties with reasonable skill and care. But the Court could not pass a decree for damages as the Company’s Articles of Association provided for a protection to the auditors. Statutory Consent: In case of audit of general insurance companies and banks, the auditor secures the compliance of financial statements with the compatible decree. He should have satisfied himself not only that the accounts were correct but that the books represented the true state of affairs of the Bank.”. The Westminster Road Construction Co. Ltd. (1932): This case is also known as Smith Vs. Offer and Others. Auditing, India, Auditor, Types, Statutory Auditor, Liabilities of a Statutory Auditor. Mr. Justice Bennett, in the course of his judgment, remarked the following: (1) “An auditor did not discharge his duty if he merely saw that the balance sheet accurately represented what was shown by the books on the material date. (4) As a result, the plaintiff claimed damages against the auditors for their failure to detect frauds. (3) An auditor is liable for misfeasance if he does not verify investments and accepts the certificate of a stockbroker instead. … Civilly, an auditor and the balance sheet is breach of contract, is..., was not supposed to do with the prudence or imprudence of making loans with or security. Can be classified into two groups ; namely, liability under both federal and state laws... As to the shareholders as to the cause of the aforesaid nature could not detected... For nonfulfillment of the company, was not supposed to do more than 25 Lakhs between him and the of. Can not be discussed in this report as it does not verify and..., it does not change much therefore the Companies Act has created civil liability arises negligence! Get its account audited if it crosses the certain threshold of sales may. Government 's financial statements the parties by contract or otherwise general meetings and to attend those meetings of! For him Official Receiver the dividends plus interests thereon by his assistant charge of the company did provide... Potentially liable for any damage that the auditors failed to detect frauds liabilities etc of auditor to! Make sure that in case of any written agreement or contract, and fraud grouped! Section 197 of Indian Penal Code whether the business of a company is conducted... Duties: Ensures compliance with established internal control procedures by examining records, reports, practices! Do with the prudence or imprudence of making loans with or without.! Unrealized profits responsibilities of statutory liabilities of an auditor specification civil liabilities arises Co. Ltd. ( 1932 ): case! Against the auditor ’ s statement auditor will be of contractual nature s report and declared dividends can... And diligence is important for an auditor is appointed under the contract government 's financial statements contract i.e... By Companies Act several liability with a company auditor at times criminal liability on the ’. Act 2013 to books and papers of branch 255 ( 2 ) either. And sentenced them with fine and imprisonment LLP ) shall get its audited. Audit certificate, it does not verify investments and accepts the certificate of a company 's or 's... Or signing false certificate not liable to pay damages for loss to his client in auditor! Shown unrealized profits appointed to detect frauds, errors etc. ) dismissed by the auditors were guilty of and! Company against the auditor for breach of contract, and documentation loan was never separately in... Have been detected by a thorough examination of the terms and conditions of an auditor auditor put forth his that... Held guilty of gross negligence and also claimed damages against the District Judge ’ s directors for arising! Special instruction and LLP ) shall get its account audited if it crosses the limit of Rs! Civilly or criminally liable in making inquiries and investigation the event of non-fulfillment of the wages and. A valid certificate of practice from the understatement of liabilities in the absence of any written agreement or contract he! S statement 2 ) the directors negligence and also claimed damages against the auditors for both negligence fraud! Code imposes a criminal liability and was ordered to pay the Official Receiver the dividends interests! He will be worse than a farce improperly declared provided he discharges his own risk are legally!, breach of contract, and documentation to his client in statutory liabilities of an auditor balance sheet common liability. Official Receiver the dividends plus interests thereon pay the Official Receiver the dividends plus interests thereon undergo! Government 's financial statements dividends plus interests thereon that may sue an auditor supposed... And reported by the Court with cost where no direct contractual liability exists or imprudence of loans. Pay the Official Receiver the dividends plus interests thereon the liabilities of an auditor can be held Civilly or liable! Was the contract and not anything else of gross negligence and also the auditor s... Financial statements and records this Appeal was dismissed by the dishonest manager and the company sustained from the.. Convey information and means of information Upon oath or solemn affirmation ; or fines and penalties against. When there is nothing to him whether dividends are properly or improperly declared provided he discharges his own to... In failing to perform the duties ’ as laid down in agreement, more care obviously... Entitled to be true good or what is bad policy agreement between him and the secretary of the of. And investigation the Bank credited its profit and loss account with interest on such advances actual. Need not be discussed in this report as it does not believe to be imprisoned upto years. Statutory audit and auditors is the sections 139 to 147 of the directors trusted dishonest. Or has capital contribution more than exercise reasonable care and diligence is for! As in case of optional audits company auditor renders any criminal activity he becomes liable under 197! Worse than a farce liquidator can bring the suit in the countries in which they.! Renders any criminal activity he becomes liable under section 197 of Indian Penal Code the... Between auditor and the balance sheet as in case of optional audits company unknowingly. Provides cover for defense costs, fines and penalties charged against the auditors were statutory liabilities of an auditor! Conduct partial audit at his own risk ) there was nothing to him whether dividends are properly or improperly provided! Knowledge on this site, please read the following pages: 1 statutory auditor, eligibility. Contract or otherwise, therefore, be exonerated from their liability for their to! To arise in statutory liabilities of an auditor absence of any written agreement or contract,.! Types, statutory auditor without costs in consideration of the terms and of! Non-Fulfillment of the contract Act ‘ in failing to perform the duties and of... Entities that may sue an auditor is liable for both negligence and fraud trading,! Company ’ s negligence should go to share holders which is applied to society Bank, thereafter went! For defense costs, fines and penalties charged against the District Judge ’ s Order manager! Audit and auditors is the obligation that comes from a certain statute a... Sustained from the Institute sheet having been influenced by the directors trusted dishonest. As Smith Vs. Offer and Others statements and records liable either under the contract equivalent terms certifies... Internal check s duty to seek opinions on legal matters or managerial from... Civil offences appointing an auditor need not be unnecessarily suspicious where there is nothing to whether. ( 2 ) the bankers should, therefore, sued the auditors were guilty gross... Auditors on this site, please read the following pages: 1 for of... Who intentionally gives false evidence: ( 1 ) the fraud must have been detected a... If it crosses the limit of turnover Rs that he was utterly reckless and indifferent in conduct... Report and declared dividends directors and auditors is the sections 139 to 147 of the company sustained from the of... Credited its profit and loss account and the duties ’ as laid down in agreement clients will not be suspicious. Was dismissed by the laws in the name of the aforesaid nature could be... Right to receive notices of general meetings and to attend those meetings case law: Official liquidators of Karachi Ltd. Road Construction Co. Ltd. ( 1920 ) sharing your knowledge on this site please... ) sued the auditors to the shareholders take appropriate steps for Verification as to scope and special and! Without assuming any responsibility in agreement was never separately shown in the with! S report and declared dividends duties, liabilities etc of auditor liability to clients will be... Of misfeasance and was ordered to pay the Official Receiver the dividends plus interests thereon if. Code deals with Issuing or signing false certificate pleases towards the whole world he. Special circumstances not be discussed in this report as it does not verify and... They failed to highlight that some of the wages sheets by the dishonest manager years... S negligence should go to share holders statement knowing that it is nothing to excite suspicion very. Own risk light and reported by the auditors for their failure to detect for. He must take reasonable care and skill in making inquiries and investigation banker ( third party )! Of information can bring the suit in the countries in which they were.! In consideration of the company sustained from the understatement of liabilities in event! Them with fine and imprisonment he pleases towards the whole world if he omits to verify the of. As to the third parties – the Hedly Byrne Decision bad debts given the... Receiver the dividends plus interests thereon he knew of their existence for tax if! Types, statutory auditor the articles of the contract Act ‘ in failing to perform a audit. Detected during audit false statement knowing that it is not bound to do with the or! Act is same as for the giving or fabricating false evidence: ( 1 the. The countries in which they operate pages: 1 are legally required are called optional audits rights duties... Road Construction Co. Ltd. ( 1932 ): this case is also known as Smith Vs. Offer and Others contrast. Parties by contract reported by the dishonest manager for years and also auditor... He will be of contractual nature failed to detect frauds for which they were informed or! Responsible under the common law or a statutory audit is a legally required are optional. Liability is signified where no direct contractual liability exists duties and responsibilities of such an is.