Many justice-focused advocates, as well as Bumpass family, had taken issue with how authorities handled the case, describing Bumpass as a young mother and community college student who was completely taken aback when detectives arrived at her doorstep with a murder warrant. Three years ago, Angel Bumpass was found guilty of murder and sentenced to 60 years in prison. : With Angel Bumpass, Christine Branstad, Alison Kanne, Shelly Carter. Angel was later sentenced to life in jail. She is currently serving in prison for first-degree felony murder. He had been fired in 2015 and indicted for tampering with evidence in a different case, according to WTCV, though the latter charges were later dismissed. With Mehak on your team, you can be sure that your content will be in good hands. The case went unsolved for a decade before Bonners loved ones pushed authorities to take a new look at Bonners murder, prompting a reexamination of physical evidence from the crime scene, according to ABC Chattanooga affiliate WTVC. Here is my thing when it comes to matching fingerprints if nobody have similar fingerprints. Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more! She was soon charged with first-degree murder and attempted aggravated robbery. For example, a mother was accused of trying to kill her son or trying to protect him, and a man was charged with murder but said he did it in self-defense. "What the law says in Tennessee is that a bond shall not be greater than what is sufficient for her to be present at court," Massey told the Times Free Press. Bill Lee: Demand a retrial for Angel Bumpass wrongfully convicted 13 year old with a life sentence Sign the Petition! On November 21, 2019, she was sentenced to life in prison for the murder count and eight years for the aggravated robbery count. In addition, both he and his wife also sold weed to the neighborhood in small quantities. Thus, the proof showed that others had a direct connection to Mr. Bonner, it did not show that the Defendant did. The Franklin Bonner murder case did not see a breakthrough that would give some scope for justice to his family for the longest time. It is respectfully submitted that this testimony created unfair prejudice to defendant by inviting speculation by the jury that defendant must have had some connection or tie to the Bonner home simply because her grandmother had possibly been there before, Massey argued in the motion.Any possible ties to the Bonner home that defendants grandmother, Shirley Bumpass, may have had would not tend to make it more probable that Angel Bumpass, her 13-year-old granddaughter, robbed and killed Franklin Bonner in his home.. Her new attorney believes she was wrongfully convicted and wants to prove she had an unfair trial. Angel lawyers never got the original duct tape to lift their on prints. After the Verdict: Angel | A&E (aetv.com). Bumpass supporters were upset and frustrated with her defense during her trial. According to Tennessee court records, Bumpass wont be able to get out of jail until February 1, 2079, which is 60 years after she was found guilty. Her new attorney believes she was wrongfully convicted and wants to prove she had an unfair trial. She rode the bus to arrive home at 2:30 pm.Nine years later on June 14, 2018, she was a 23 year old mother of two, in her second year of school enrolled at Jefferson Community and Technical College. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. The order appealed revoked Appellant's five-year suspended sentence which Appellant received on August 31, 1993, for Knowingly Concealing or Withholding Stolen Property. CRF-93-588. At the time of trial, Bumpass was 24; Vaughn was 37; she was convicted; he was found not guilty on both counts. Rather, the principal, if not only, link between these two persons consisted of a Facebook connection between Mr. Vaughn and a mutual third-party acquaintance, Cordarel Bumpass, that existed some ten years later. . Neighborhood Association Angel Burt coined Jones . Well for one moment lets say the police DID NOT have any evidence. Tennessee Department of Correction. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. "So much of what we see and hear around crimes and convictions is dramatized or delivered for effect, so it is essential to show this is actually how appeals work and what they mean.". Ruby Design Company. Contact La Shawn Pagn at lpagan@timesfreepress.com or 423-757-6476. No one payed attention to the fact that when Angel was 13, that was only 50, and weighted a mere 80 pounds. Also, a strand of hair was found on the duct tgape, which too, hasnt been checked for evidence. Bumpass has been serving her sentence in a Nashville prison since 2019. Thus, a petition came to effect, spearheaded by the general public asking Governor Lee and other authorities to look into this matter. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Your email address will not be published. The two fingerprints that were tested came back as a positive match to that of Angel Bumpass, a local resident from the same area as Bonner. Angel Lynn, 19, fell into the road after being bundled into a van by Chay Bowskill. Is Garcelle Beauvais Married, Who Is Garcelle Beauvais Married To? Though there are questionable circumstances regarding the evidence and testimonies given, one cannot help but be intrigued by how the case has been able to come to its various conclusions. . This petition starter stood up and took action. Bumpass Was Given A Life Sentence And Will Not Be Eligible For Release Until 2079 . Shawn Mendes And Sabrina Carpenter Step Out Together. I havent watched the entire show yet but the aunt makes 4-10 k a week? Has anyone heard of Angel Bumpass' story? Read More About Us. People have doubt when it comes to Angel's innocent. Essentially, the court found that the prosecutor asked a loaded question and had done so despite the co-defendants own attorney objecting to a substantially similar question just minutes before. On January 16,2009 Angel Bumpass was eighth grade star roll student . People believe that the attorney did a poor job representing Angel Bumpass's case and she did not receive adequate legal assistance from them. [T]he Court reaffirms its finding that the evidence is legally sufficient to support the Defendants convictions, Judge Tom Greenholtz writes. I just dont understand how the jury found a woman, who was 13 at the time guilty of murder that was insane. So now you ask me why didn't Angel have a fingerprint expert. Brinkworth revealed the follow-up episode was created to satisfy the viewers' need to know more about the case. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Bonner was bound to a kitchen table and chair with duct tape around his feet, arms, head, nose and mouth. Judge Tom Greenholz set the sentencing date for Ms. Bumpass for . Around 6 that morning two detectives came to her door, shockingly, with a warrant for a felony murder to be served to Angel from May 2018. "In Angel's case, it was clear that our audience wanted to know more about her, about why it had happened, and about whether there would be remedial measures taken to rectify what many perceived to be an injustice," Brinkworth said. . The parents of a teenager who suffered catastrophic brain damage . Bumpass appeal will be handled by a different legal team than her original trial, Heavy has learned. During Friday's hearing, Massey filed a motion to allow Bumpass supervised freedom via GPS monitoring until the conclusion of the new trial. "When you have the opportunity to engage with a large audience about the practical realities of illustrating how the criminal appeals process works, you have to take that opportunity, and Angel, her family, her attorneys and the courts were fantastic in helping us deliver that to screen.". The tape in question also had nine other fingerprints that are unknown and were not investigated. A woman serving a life sentence in a Tennessee prison was granted a retrial for the 2009 murder she was accused of carrying out at just 13 years-old. On May 12, 2020, the show came back with its fourth episode, Cold Case Killer or Innocent Teenage Girl? In past episodes, the show looked at some complicated cases from the defendants points of view. She was 13, weighing under 100lbs.. Heavy has learned that Bumpass appeal will be handled by a different group of lawyers than the ones who worked on her trial. Garth Best . The victims wife denied knowing or seeing the Defendant previously, and although the State linked the Defendants aunt to the victim, Ms. Bonner denied ever seeing the Defendant when the aunt came to the Bonner house. returned with its fourth episode Cold Case Killer or Innocent Teenage Girl? on May 12, 2020. Is Shawn Mendes Dating Singer Sabrina Carpenter? The Justice for Angel Bumpass site strives for support for a retrial motion and financial support for her family, who are said to be overwhelmed by legal fees, says wikibious. The Tennessee woman convicted on felony murder and robbery charges won a new trial after years of demanding that she was framed and had no knowledge of the crime. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. The medical examiner declared that the cause of death was due to suffocation. According to him, Vaughn confided about the murder to him and said: duct-taped someone up like a mummy, and it went wrong. What Cheaton said about the crime bore a strong resemblance to how Bonner was found at the crime scene, and hence, Vaughn was regarded as a suspect. The two fingerprints that were tested came back as a positive match to that of Angel Bumpass, a local resident from the same area as Bonner. With her strong writing skills, in-depth knowledge of the entertainment industry, and passion for the subject matter, Mehak is the perfect choice for anyone looking for well-written, engaging and informative content on the latest celebrity news and gossip. In 2016, Fields was booked on several charges of sexual harassment, coaching witnesses and tampering with evidence. The judge then listed several instances in which he found the states presentation deficient, including the lack of a connection between Bumpass and Bonner, and the lack of any link between the defendant and her co-defendant at the time of Bonners death. Massey also claimed the state should not have questioned Franklin Bonners wife, Linda Bonner, on the stand about whether or not she knew Bumpass grandmother, Shirley Bumpass, according to the motion. Concerned Citizens for Justice. Snitched dude shouldn't have been on trial at all. The evidence they have is two finger prints. At the time, fingerprints found from the duct tapes were run by Detective Karl Fields to reveal that it did not find any matches. A Hamilton County Criminal Court jury found a woman guilty of a 2009 cold case murder Thursday night. In addition, the verdict does not sit well with many, as several other fingerprints were also found on the tape, which has not been sourced out yet. Because Angel's . Instead, he saw kindness. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. An intimate account of what happens when someone is formally charged with a crime and sent to trial as told by the perspective of the accused, their legal team and their family members. How Long Does Weed (Marijuana) Stay In Your System? A woman named Angel Bumpass was tied to Franklin Bonners death in 2019 and then tried alongside a co-defendant, Mallory Vaughn. Whoever killed him wrapped his head, face and mouth in duct tape, resulting in his suffocation. In her free time, Mehak indulges in her hobbies of watching Netflix series, reading celebrity's magazines, and dancing. Brinkworth said the follow-up episode was made to satisfy the audience's need to know more about the case. Time When Kelly Clarkson Lost 37 Pound Weight Using This Trick! She accepted to the nursing program to begin the program in August 2018. It, however, saw a new change of events in 2019, after a decade since the crime took place. She had been 13 years-old at the time of the murder. . A petition is circulating on Change.org to demand a retrial in Angel Bumpass case. Crime News is your destination for true crime stories from around the world, breaking crime news, and information about Oxygen's original true crime shows and documentaries. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. September 25, 2022 5 Mins Read. Your email address will not be published. Angel Bumpass appears in a 2020 prison photograph. The show explored some complex cases in previous episodes, showing viewers the perspective of the defendants after they are accused of a crime, including a case debating whether a mother attempted to kill her son or was trying to protect him and a man charged with murder who pleaded self-defense. Nevertheless, the jury convicted Bumpass and acquitted a co-defendant for whom there was no physical evidence. The case did not see much of a lead except the statement made by a federal inmate named Nicholas Cheaton, who said that he believed his cousin was responsible for the crime. In a late August ruling and order, a Hamilton County Criminal Court noted several errors and other deficiencies with the defendants trial. The condemned woman, and her legions of defenders online, have always maintained she was wrongfully convicted. Top 10 Deadliest Snakes In The World, What Is The Most Deadliest Snake In The World? All Rights Reserved. On a website called Justice for Angel Bumpass, people are asking for help with both a motion for a new trial and money for her family, who are said to be struggling to pay their legal bills. Description: Angel Bumpass was found guilty of murder and sentenced to 60 years in prison; her new attorney believes she was wrongfully convicted and wants to prove she had an unfair trial; whether he will succeed in winning an appeal and securing her release. Contributed photo / From left, attorney Seth Segraves, defendant Angel Bumpass and attorney William Massey attend Bumpass' bond hearing Nov. 3. A woman's push along with her attorneys for a new trial after being convicted in the 2009 homicide of a Chattanooga man . The 26-year-old woman is serving her time at the Debra K. Johnson Rehabilitation Center in Nashville, which used to be called the Tennessee Prison for Women. This statement was repeated three times by Mr. Smith before the inquiry moved to other topics, and this statement communicated to the jury that even members of the Defendants own family believed that the proof at the trial demonstrated her guilt, Greenholtz noted. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. The Tech Education. We won a battle at this point, but we still have a war in front of us. Three years ago, Angel Bumpass was found guilty of murder and sentenced to 60 years in prison. "The justice system is as good as the laws we have, the people who work in it and the jurors who decide the verdict," Brinkworth said, "so hopefully people will watch an episode like this and feel a little bit more ready to step into a jury box.". Angel Bumpass' case is being called for a new trial through a petition on Change.org. Who Is Chris Martin Ex Wife? However, when a new investigator ran the duct tape for a re-test, two fingerprints were obtained, and none of them belonged to Vaughn. To show that she was not culpable of anything of that natural. Only recently has his sentence been reduced to . Nadia Nakai Dating History, Who Is Courteney Cox Dating? Courteney Cox And Johnny Mcdaid Relationship Timeline. Copyright 2023, Chattanooga Times Free Press, Inc. The case had gone cold when relatives of the victim asked prosecutors to take another look 10 years after the fact. WATCH LIVE: Psychic on Trial in Spousal Swindling Case, WATCH LIVE: XXXTentacion murder trial 3 men charged in 2018 shooting death of rapper, WATCH LIVE: Murdaugh Family Double-Murder Trial, Law&Crime Looks Ahead to 10 Remarkable Criminal Trials Scheduled for the First Half of 2023, 9 Shocking Times Defendants Testified at Trial, Prosecutors to ask judge to clear man wrongfully convicted in brutal rape and murder of woman whose body was found in trunk, Manipulative psychic coached 20-something woman on bilking and kissing 80-year-old businessman: Prosecutors, Elderly Florida man caught with over one ton of printed child porn images in home: Sheriff, Says it all: experts react to Buster Murdaughs facepalm during fathers testimony in double murder trial, Sedition Panda allegedly hopped over barricades to breach Capitol on Jan. 6, now faces felony charges. Angel was just 13 at the time of Franklin's death. Haley Andersons Death: 5 Fast Facts You Need to Know. In late August, a Hamilton County Criminal Court ruled that there were enough errors in the . What if two people match would they have had to match more ridges than? [emailprotected]. Angel Bumpass was charged in the death of 68-year-old Franklin Bonner last year, after the . "I don't know why, when you have less proof, on a lady that shows up and has a track record of showing up, you'd want to increase the bond.". Girls Appeal And Update 2022 Heavenly Messenger Bumpass was framed for lawful felony murder when she was just thirteen years old, and it is respected that she was wrongly convicted and sentenced to life in prison accordingly. The Hamilton County medical examiner later ruled his death a homicide by suffocation. That should have been corrected by the trial court as well. 2022 Foxiz News Network. A Justice for Angel Bumpass website seeks both support for a retrial motion and financial support for her family, who are said to be overwhelmed by legal fees. In the case of Angel Bumpass, who is featured on A&E . Massey said he was absolutely thrilled when he received then news about a new trial on August 31, but said it wasnt quite a done deal yet: The state has the right to appeal the judge's decision within 30 days of the ruling. During her testimony, she said the evidence didnt look good for Bumpass. In 2009, 68-year-old Franklin Bonnerwas tied to a table and chair during an alleged robbery attempt in Chattanooga. Angel Bumpass, 27, is a woman serving a life sentence in a Tennessee prison and has been granted a retrial for a 2009 murder she was accused of carrying out at when she was just 13 years-old. . Prosecutors indicated they would oppose supervised release at a Nov. 3 hearing -- and would argue for an increase in Bumpass' bond. Bartholomew spent his summer vacation poring over court transcripts of Angel Bumpass' 2019 murder trial. Cold Case Killer or Innocent Teenage Girl? He also said her original bond amount of $300,000 should be lowered to $75,000. https://t.co/6KdyWG6R56, A&E True Crime (@AETVTrueCrime) May 12, 2020. On October 3, 2019, tens years later Angel Bumpass was found guilty of a murder that was committed in 2009, by a jury after only 4 hours and 30 minutes approximately of deliberation. Department of CorrectionDebra K. Johnson Rehabilitation Center in Nashville, Tennessee. . The episode will feature audio interviews with Bumpass while incarcerated, as well as snippets of her life since being free on bond. Center, formerly known as the Tennessee Prison for Women, when she was granted a new trial last year by former Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Tom Greenholtz. The case was the subject of episode 75 of the "Women & Crime" podcast, as well as being the subject of the May 12, 2020, episode of A&E's "Accused: Guilty or Innocent?" She was 13 at the time of Bonner's death. The jury took just over four and a half hours to decide that she was guilty of first-degree felony murder and trying to commit especially serious robbery. Linda Bonner admitted this during the course of the cases trial. Angel was one of two people originally charged with killing Franklin Bonner, a 68-year-old man, who was bound and . After the Verdict: Angel. A breakthrough was presumed to have happened when Nicholas Cheaton, a federal inmate, convicted of a bank robbery, came forward to say that Mallory Vaughn, his cousin, was behind the murder. All Rights Reserved. Angel Bumpass, 27, was tied to Bonner's death in 2019 and tried alongside a co-defendant, 40-year-old Mallory Vaughn. Angel Bumpass With Her Two Daughters. With a keen eye for detail and a passion for storytelling, Mehak has been crafting compelling and engaging content for over 3 years. we try not to take a stance around whether or not a verdict is fair or not -- we try to be as neutral as we can be within the specific perspective of the show (following the defense).". Though many details post-conviction is not made available, there has been a petition on the rise demanding a fair trial for Bumpass. On November 21, she was sentenced to life in prison for the . Latest Update: A detention or release hearing for defendant Darius Moore is scheduled for January 27, 2023 at 01:30 PM. This is because, at the time, no fingerprints were found. Also, a strand of hair was found on the duct tgape, which too, hasnt been checked for evidence. A status hearing for Angel is set before Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn on 29th March. Fingerprints: No two people have the same finger prints according to ''experts''.Well lets dive deeper in to finger prints.FIRST, you have more than 150 ridges( lines and loops on the fingerprint)Second, Tennessee just has to match 12 of those ridges to say there are your fingerprints. In 2009, Franklin Bonner was found murdered in his residence. Thus, the. At the age of thirteen, Angel Bumpass was framed for felony murder, wrongfully convicted and sentenced to life in prison. With Garth Best, Franklin Bonner, Linda Bonner, Angel Bumpass. Angel Bumpass, now 27, was one of two people originally charged with killing Franklin Bonner, 68, who was bound and suffocated to death in his Washington Hills home in Chattanooga, Tennessee on Jan. 19, 2009, according to the Chattanooga Times Free Press. Demand a retrial for Angel Bumpass wrongfully convicted 13 year old with a life sentence. A Hamilton County medical examiner later determined Bonner died of suffocation and ruled the death a homicide. Bumpass lawyers also never got to do their own testing of the evidence presented. Would you still have doubt? He had duct tape around his feet, arms, head, nose and mouth. She was convicted last year at the age of 23 and given a life sentence. This was over nine years after the murder happened. According to him, Vaughn confided about the murder to him and, A strand of hair was also found on the tape, which is also believed to not have been tested.